Apple Mac OS X da Windows XP Performance Daidai

01 na 09

Gabatarwa da Bayani

Windows XP a kan Intel Based Mac Mini. © Mark Kyrnin

Gabatarwar

A bara, Apple ya sanar da cewa sun yi nufin canzawa ta amfani da hardware na PowerPC zuwa IBM zuwa na'urorin sarrafa kwamfuta. Wannan ya kawo babban bege cewa mutane da suke so su gudanar da tsarin Windows da Mac a kan dandalin dandalin. A lokacin da aka saki, waɗannan bege sun rushe ta hanyar gane cewa Microsoft installers ba zai aiki ba.

A ƙarshe an yi hamayya don gina kyauta ga mutumin da ya fara samo hanyoyin da aka tsara domin shigar da Windows XP akan Mac. An kammala wannan gwagwarmaya kuma an ba da sakamakon zuwa ga masu ba da izini a kan OnMac.net. Tare da wannan yanzu yana samuwa, yana yiwuwa a kwatanta tsarin tsarin aiki biyu ga juna.

Windows XP akan Mac

Wannan labarin ba zai zamo dalla-dalla ba game da yadda za a samu tsarin tsarin Windows wanda aka sanya a kan kwamfutar Mac na Intel. Wadanda ke nemo wannan bayanin ya kamata su ziyarci "YADDA ZA" FAQ da aka samu akan shafin yanar gizo OnMac.net. Bayan ya fada haka, zan yi wasu 'yan bayani game da tsari da kuma wasu masu amfani da abubuwa su kamata su sani.

Na farko, hanyar da aka tsara za ta samar da tsarin taya kawai. Ba zai yiwu a cire Mac OS X gaba ɗaya ba kuma kawai shigar Windows XP akan tsarin kwamfutar. Wannan har yanzu ana binciken shi ta hanyar al'umma. Na biyu, ana tafiyar da direbobi na kayan aiki tare da sauran masu sayar dasu. Shigar da su zai iya zama tricky. Wasu abubuwa ba su da har yanzu suna aiki da direbobi.

Hardware da Software

02 na 09

Hardware da Software

Hardware

Don manufar wannan labarin, an ƙera Mac Mini na Mac na Intel don kwatanta tsarin Windows XP da Mac OS X. Dalilin farko na Mac Mini zaɓi shi ne cewa yana da goyon bayan direba mafi kyawun samfurori na Intel wanda ke samuwa. An sabunta tsarin zuwa cikakkun sakonni na samfurin da aka samo daga shafin yanar gizon Apple kuma suna kamar haka:

Software

Software yana da muhimmiyar ɓangare na wannan aikin kwatanta. Tsarin tsarin aiki guda biyu da aka yi amfani dashi a cikin kwatanta shine ma'aikatan Windows XP da Service Pack 2 da kuma Mac OS X version 10.4.5. An shigar da su ta hanyar amfani da hanyoyin da aka tsara ta hanyar umarnin da aka samar da shafin yanar gizo na OnMac.net.

Don manufar kwatanta tsarin tsarin aiki guda biyu, da yawa ayyuka masu mahimmanci na kwamfuta waɗanda masu amfani da kullum suka yi sun zaba. Na gaba, aikin shine neman software wanda zai gudana a tsarin tsarin aiki wanda ya dace. Wannan aiki ne mai wuyar gaske kamar yadda wasu za a iya haɗuwa don dandamali guda biyu, amma da dama an rubuta su kawai ne ko ɗaya. A lokuta kamar waɗannan, aikace-aikacen biyu da ayyuka masu kama da aka zaɓa.

Ayyuka na Duniya da Tsarin Fayil

03 na 09

Aikace-aikace na Duniya da Tsarin Fayil

Shirye-shirye na Universal

Ɗaya daga cikin matsaloli tare da sauyawa daga ginin PowerPC RISC zuwa Intel yana nufin cewa aikace-aikace zai bukaci a sake rubutawa. Don taimakawa gudun saurin aiwatar da miƙa mulki, Apple ya bunkasa Rosetta. Wannan aikace-aikacen da ke gudana a cikin tsarin OS X na hanyar sarrafawa kuma yana fassara code daga tsofaffiyar PowerPC software don gudana ƙarƙashin na'urorin Intel. Sabbin sababbin aikace-aikacen da za su gudana a ƙasa a ƙarƙashin OS ana kiransa Universal Applications.

Duk da yake wannan tsarin yana aiki ba tare da wata hanya ba, akwai hasara ta hanyar yin amfani da Aikace-aikacen Ba da Ƙari. Apple ya lura cewa shirye-shiryen da ke gudana a ƙarƙashin Rosetta a kan Macs masu basira na Intel za su kasance da sauri kamar tsarin tsarin PowerPC. Duk da haka ba su faɗi yadda yawancin aikin ya ɓace ba yayin da yake gudana ƙarƙashin Rosetta kwatanta shirin shirin Universal. Tun da yake ba dukkan aikace-aikacen da aka yi amfani da shi ba har zuwa sabon dandamali, wasu daga cikin gwaje-gwajen da aka yi da shirye-shiryen ba na Universal. Zan yi bayanin kula lokacin da na yi amfani da irin waɗannan shirye-shiryen a cikin gwajin mutum.

Tsarin fayil

Duk da yake gwaje-gwaje suna amfani da wannan kayan aiki, aikace-aikacen software sun bambanta. Ɗaya daga cikin waɗannan bambance-bambance da za su iya tasiri tasirin rumbun kwamfutarka shine tsarin tsarin da kowane tsarin aiki yake amfani dasu. Windows XP yana amfani da NTFS yayin da Mac OS X ke amfani da HPFS. Kowace fayilolin ɗin suna kula da bayanai a hanyoyi daban-daban. Saboda haka, koda da aikace-aikace irin wannan, damar samun bayanai zai iya haifar da sauyawa a cikin aikin.

Kayan Fayil na Fayil

04 of 09

Kayan Fayil na Fayil

Win XP da Mac OS X Kwafi Kwafi Test. © Mark Kyrnin

Kayan Fayil na Fayil

Tare da manufar cewa kowane OS yana amfani da tsarin fayil daban, Na ɗauka gwadawa mai sauƙi don tsarin tsarin fayil zai iya taimakawa wajen ƙayyade yadda wannan zai iya tasiri wasu gwaje-gwaje. Jarabawar ta shafi yin amfani da ayyukan ƙirar na tsarin aiki don zaɓar fayiloli daga kwakwalwa mai nisa, kwashe su zuwa ƙwaƙwalwar gida da kuma tsawon lokacin da ake dauka. Tun da wannan yana amfani da ayyukan ƙirar aiki a duka tsarin aiki, babu wani tasiri a kan hanyar Mac.

Matakan gwaji

  1. Haɗa 250GB USB 2.0 hard drive zuwa Mac Mini
  2. Zaɓi shugabanci wanda ya ƙunshi fayiloli 8,000 (9.5GB) a cikin kundayen adireshi daban-daban
  3. Kwafi umarnin da aka zaɓa a kan ɓangaren ƙwaƙwalwar ajiyar ƙira
  4. Lokacin fara kwafin zuwa ƙarshe

Sakamako

Sakamakon wannan gwajin ya nuna cewa tsarin Windows NTFS ya bayyana ya zama sauri a aikin aikin rubuta bayanai zuwa rumbun kwamfutarka idan aka kwatanta da tsarin HP HP +. Wannan yana iya yiwuwa saboda cewa tsarin NTFS ba shi da siffofin da yawa kamar tsarin HPFS. Tabbas, wannan jarabawa ne wanda yafi yawan bayanai fiye da mai amfani da kullum zai magance shi yanzu.

Duk da haka, masu amfani ya kamata su sani cewa ɗakunan ayyuka na faifai yana iya kasancewa da hankali a kan tsarin Mac OS X na asali idan aka kwatanta da tsarin Windows na ainihi. Gaskiyar cewa Mac Mini ta amfani da kundin kwamfutar kundin rubutu yana nufin cewa wannan aikin zai kasance da hankali fiye da mafi yawan tsarin kwamfuta.

Taswirar fayil ɗin fayil

05 na 09

Fayil din Ajiye Talla

Win XP da Mac OS X Fayil din Amfani. © Mark Kyrnin

Taswirar fayil ɗin fayil

A yau da shekaru, masu amfani suna tattara adadin bayanai akan kwakwalwarsu. Fayil na bidiyo, hotuna da kiɗa na iya cinye wuri. Ajiye wannan bayanan shine wani abu da mai yawa ya kamata mu yi. Wannan kuma jarabawa ne mai kyau game da tsarin fayil har ma da aikin mai sarrafawa a ƙaddamar da bayanai a cikin tarihin.

An yi wannan gwaji ta yin amfani da shirin RAR 3.51 wanda yake samuwa ga Windows XP da Mac OS X kuma za'a iya gudu daga layin umarni da ke guje wa ɗakilfan hoto. Aikace-aikace na RAR ba kayan aiki ne na duniya ba ne kuma yana gudana a ƙarƙashin jagoran Rosetta.

Matakan gwaji

  1. Bude bude ko kwamiti na umarni
  2. Yi amfani da umarnin RAR don zaɓar da damfara 3.5GB na bayanai a cikin fayil guda ɗaya
  3. Tsarin lokaci har zuwa ƙarshe

Sakamako

Bisa ga sakamakon nan, tsarin karkashin tsarin tsarin Windows yana da kimanin 25% sauri fiye da wannan aiki a karkashin Mac OS X. Duk da yake aikace-aikacen rar yana gudana ƙarƙashin Rosetta, aikin da aka sauke daga wannan zai yiwu ya fi ƙanƙan da bambanci a tsarin fayil. Bayan haka, jarrabawar da aka yi a baya da aka nuna ta nuna irin wannan nauyin 25% yayin da kawai rubuta bayanai zuwa drive.

Nazarin Juyawa na Juye

06 na 09

Nazarin Juyawa na Juye

Win XP da Mac OS X iTunes Test Test Audio. © Mark Kyrnin

Nazarin Juyawa na Juye

Tare da shahararren iPod da na dijital a kan kwakwalwa, yin jarrabawar aikace-aikacen mai jiwuwa wani zaɓi ne mai mahimmanci. Koda yake, Apple yana samar da aikace-aikacen iTunes don Windows XP da kuma na asali don sabon Intel Mac OS X a matsayin Fayil na Universal. Wannan ya sa yin amfani da wannan aikace-aikacen cikakke don gwaji.

Tun da shigo da sauti zuwa kwamfutarka an iyakance ga gudun mai kwakwalwa, sai na yanke shawarar gwada gudu daga cikin shirye-shiryen ta hanyar juyan fayil na WAV mai tsawon 22min da aka shigo da shi daga CD zuwa tsarin fayil na AAC. Wannan zai ba da mafi kyawun yadda aikace-aikacen ke aiki tare da na'ura mai sarrafawa da tsarin fayil.

Matakan gwaji

  1. A karkashin Dalalai na iTunes, zaɓi hanyar AAC don Ana shigowa
  2. Zaɓi fayil ɗin WAV a cikin iTunes Library
  3. Zaɓi "Zaɓuɓɓukan Hanya zuwa AAC" daga menu na dama
  4. Tsarin lokaci zuwa ƙarshe

Sakamako

Ba kamar gwaje-gwajen da suka gabata na tsarin fayil ba, wannan gwajin ya nuna cewa duka shirin Windows XP da Mac OS X sun kasance a kan kafa. Mafi yawan wannan za a iya danganta ga gaskiyar cewa Apple ya rubuta lambar don aikace-aikacen kuma ya tattara shi a asali don amfani da kayan aikin Intel kamar yadda ba tare da tsarin Windows ko Mac OS X ba.

Editing Editing Test

07 na 09

Editing Editing Test

Windows XP da Mac OS X Gyara Tambaya. © Mark Kyrnin

Editing Editing Test

Don wannan gwaji na yi amfani da GIMP (GNU Image Manipulation Program) version 2.2.10 wanda yake samuwa ga tsarin aiki guda biyu. Wannan ba aikace-aikacen Universal ba ne na Mac kuma yana gudana tare da Rosetta. Bugu da ƙari, Na sauke wani shahararren rubutun da ake kira mai tsada-tsalle don tsaftace hotuna. Wannan tare da zane mai suna Old Photo script daga shirin GIMP an yi amfani dashi a kan guda 5 na megapixel na dijital don kwatantawa.

Matakan gwaji

  1. Fayil din hoto a GIMP
  2. Zaɓi Almani | Warp-Sharp daga Menu-Fu Menu
  3. Latsa Ok don amfani da saitunan tsoho
  4. Rubutun lokaci zuwa ƙarshe
  5. Zabi Décor | Tsohon Hotuna daga Menu-Fu Menu
  6. Latsa Ok don amfani da saitunan tsoho
  7. Rubutun lokaci zuwa ƙarshe

Sakamako

Warp-Sharp Script

Tsohon Hotuna na Hotuna

A cikin wannan gwaji, muna ganin kashi 22% da 30% da sauri daga aikace-aikacen da ke gudana a cikin Windows XP a kan Mac OS X. Tun da aikace-aikacen ba ya amfani da raƙuman disk a duk lokacin wannan tsari, ana iya nuna ratawar aiki ga Gaskiyar cewa dole ne a fassara lambar ta hanyar Rosetta.

Fitar da Magana na Digital Digital

08 na 09

Fitar da Magana na Digital Digital

Windows XP da Mac OS X Digital Test Test. © Mark Kyrnin

Fitar da Magana na Digital Digital

Ban sami tsarin da aka rubuta don Windows XP da Mac OS X ba don gwajin. A sakamakon haka, na zabi aikace-aikacen biyu waɗanda ke da nau'ikan ayyuka masu kama da zasu iya canza fayil na AVI daga camcorder na DV a cikin DVD. Don Windows, na zaɓi aikace-aikacen Nero 7 yayin da aka yi amfani da shirin iDVD 6 na Mac OS X. iDVD wani Aikace-aikacen Universal ne wanda Apple ya rubuta kuma baya amfani da watau Rosetta.

Matakan gwaji

iDVD 6 Matakai

  1. Bude iDVD 6
  2. Bude "Ɗaya daga Mataki daga Fayil Gizon"
  3. Zaɓi Fayil
  4. Lokaci har sai an kammala DVD

Nero 7 Matakai

  1. Bude Nero StartSmart
  2. Zaži Bidiyo DVD | Hotuna da Bidiyo | Yi Rinku DVD-Video
  3. Ƙara Fayil zuwa Hanya
  4. Zaɓi Next
  5. Zaɓi "Kada ku ƙirƙiri wani menu"
  6. Zaɓi Next
  7. Zaɓi Next
  8. Zaɓi ƙone
  9. Lokaci har sai an kammala DVD

Sakamako

A wannan yanayin, fassarar bidiyon daga fayilolin DV ɗin zuwa DVD yana da 34% sauri a karkashin Nero 7 akan Windows XP fiye da iDVD 6 akan Mac OS X. Yanzu sun yarda sune shirye-shiryen daban daban waɗanda suke amfani da lambar daban-daban saboda haka ana sa ran sakamakon zama daban. Babban mahimmanci a cikin aiki shine wataƙila sakamakon sakamakon tsarin fayil ko da yake. Duk da haka, tare da duk matakai don yin wannan fasalin a Nero idan aka kwatanta da iDVD, tsarin Apple yana da sauki ga mabukaci.

Ƙarshe

09 na 09

Ƙarshe

Bisa ga gwaje-gwajen da sakamakon, ya nuna cewa tsarin Windows XP shine ainihin mafi kyawun wasan kwaikwayo idan ya zo da aiwatar da aikace-aikace idan aka kwatanta da Mac OS X tsarin aiki. Wannan raguwa zai iya zama kamar 34% sauri a aikace-aikace guda biyu. Bayan ya fada haka, akwai wasu lambobin da zan yi bayani.

Da farko shine mafi yawan aikace-aikacen da aka yi a wannan gwaji sun gudana a karkashin jagorancin Rosetta saboda rashin kayan aiki na Universal. Lokacin da aka yi amfani da Aikace-aikacen Universal kamar iTunes aka yi amfani da shi babu bambanci. Wannan yana nufin cewa haɗin aikin zai yiwu a rufe a tsakanin tsarin aiki guda biyu yayin da ake amfani da aikace-aikacen da ake amfani da shi zuwa ga binaryar Universal. Saboda wannan, Ina fatan in sake duba wannan gwaji a cikin kimanin watanni shida ko haka lokacin da yawancin aikace-aikacen sun tuba don ganin abin da bambanci ya kasance a yanzu.

Na biyu, akwai bambanci a cikin tsarin aiki da kuma amfani. Duk da yake windows yana yin mafi kyau a cikin gwaji, adadin rubutu da menus wanda mai amfani yana buƙatar shiga ta hanyar kammala aikin yana da sauƙi akan Mac OS X idan aka kwatanta da Windows XP ke dubawa. Wannan na iya sa bambancin nishaɗi maras amfani ga wadanda basu iya gano yadda ake amfani da aikace-aikacen ba.

A ƙarshe, tsarin shigar da Windows XP a kan Mac ba hanya mai sauƙi ba kuma ba a bada shawarar a wannan lokaci ga waɗanda basu da masaniya akan kwakwalwa.